Distribution of blood lead and cadmium levels in healthy children aged 0 to 18 years and analysis of related influencing factors in Henan, China: data findings from 2017 to 2022

With the development of modern industry and transportation, heavy metal pollutants are gradually exposed and released, and heavy metal pollution in the environment is becoming increasingly serious, and the resulting harm to human health has caused widespread concern. Heavy metals in the environment can enter the human body through a variety of pathways, and children in particular are a susceptible population to environmental pollution [1]. Many studies have revealed that children are more sensitive to heavy metal toxicity because they are in the early stages of rapid growth and development, and their blood-brain barrier and immune system are not yet sufficiently developed [2‐4]. Thus, long-term heavy metal exposure will have adverse effects on children's intelligence and growth and development, which will easily lead to multiple damages in children [2‐4].

Heavy metals lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd) are toxic and harmful substances widely present in production and living environment, causing environmental pollution and also seriously threatening human health. Lead and cadmium are the two heavy metals that pose the greatest threat to children's health in the environment [4]. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) has classified lead and cadmium as human carcinogens (Group I), and childhood Pb poisoning and Cd poisoning have become a global public health problem that has caused widespread concern worldwide [4‐6]. The effects of Pb exposure on children's health are multifaceted and include intellectual impairment [7], cognitive deficits [8], adverse behavioral outcomes [9], low birth weight/height [10], and negative consequences on bone composition and development [3], which can be observed even at low levels of exposure [11]. In 2012, the United State (US) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Advisory Committee on Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention concluded that there was no safe level of Pb exposure and revised the reference value from 100µg/L to 50µg/L. This reference value was based on 97.5% of blood lead concentrations in the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) population and served as a trigger point to guide clinical and public health interventions [12]. Afterwards, 35µg/L was recommended to the CDC as a cut-off value based on NHANES survey data from 2011-2014, and this concentration is still under review [13]. Cadmium is a toxic heavy metal that has no physiological role in the human body and can cause damage to many systems such as bone, nerve, immune, respiratory, circulatory, urinary and reproductive. Studies have indicated that Cd intake can increase the risk of cancer and death and lead to kidney damage and decrease bone mineral density, which can lead to diseases such as osteochondrosis and osteoporosis [14]. Low blood cadmium levels (BCLs) may be associated with adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes or neurobehavioral manifestations [15]. There is also no available reference safe level of Cd exposure in children.

In China, with the phasing out of leaded gasoline in 2000, blood lead levels (BLLs) in children dropped dramatically, such a conclusion was made by reviewing blood Pb (PbB) studies conducted across China [16]. However, some relevant sources of Pb exposures in children still persist, such as exposure through food, drinking water, tobacco smoke and contaminated dust particles [17]. Cadmium is readily absorbed by various plants, such as vegetables, grains and tobacco. Tobacco smoke is volatile and can be effectively absorbed after inhalation and is a major source of exposure [17]. From a public health perspective, there is an urgent need for adequate information on adverse events related to Pb and Cd exposure. Blood samples are still one of the most commonly accepted options for laboratory analysis to assess recent and past exposure to chemical contaminants. Whole blood has been the preferred biofluid for assessing Pb exposure, both for screening and diagnosis and for long-term biomonitoring. BLL remains the most reliable indicator of recent Pb exposure [9]. Cd enters the body and binds mainly to blood cells, and BCL can represent recent Cd exposure [18].

Most of the available studies on BLLs and BCLs in children have focused on areas with Pb and Cd contamination [19, 20]. Alternatively, studies have been conducted on non-healthy children (usually a group of children with certain diseases) [21], or have monitored the results of the survey only for a certain age group [16‐18]. There is still a lack of data on BLLs and BCLs in healthy children of all ages from 0 to 18 years in China. This study was performed to analyze the BLLs and BCLs in healthy children aged 0-18 years from 2017 to 2022 in urban and rural areas of Henan Province, Central China, as well as their relationships with socio-demographic variables and certain relevant exposure factors. To provide a basis for evaluating public health policy development and exposure risk management.

A total of 25,920 study subjects meeting the inclusion and exclusion criteria were included in this study, of which 62.3% were boys, and the median age was 2.58 (1.00,6.25) years. After grouping by age, the largest proportion of children in the 1 to 3 years group and the smallest proportion of children in the 13 to 18 years group were among all study participants. A total of 5843 children were enrolled in 2017, 5099 in 2018, 4421 in 2019, 3659 in 2020, 3765 in 2021, and 3133 in 2022. The differences in the distribution of gender, age, ethnicity, frequent playgrounds, heating fuel, frequency of staying in rooms with smokers, frequency of non-alcoholic beverage intake, and annual household income were statistically significant between years (P<0.001), and there were no differences in the distribution of the study population's place of residence. The details of the sociodemographic characteristics of the sample of children in this study were presented in Table 1.

Table 2 revealed that the overall median blood Pb concentration of the included study subjects was 23.48µg/L and the median blood Cd concentration was 0.66µg/L. The median blood Pb concentration was higher in boys (23.90µg/L) than in girls (22.75µg/L) (P<0.001). The difference between the median blood Cd concentrations of boys and girls was not statistically significant (P=0.489). Figure 1B visualized the distribution of blood Pb and blood Cd concentrations by gender. We also analyzed the distribution of blood Pb and Cd concentrations by gender under different years (Fig. 1D), and by gender in different age subgroups (Fig. 2D). It was also observed that the blood Pb concentration was higher in boys than in girls regardless of the grouping. In addition, the median blood Pb concentration and median blood Cd concentration varied with age group and year. Figures 1A and 2A graphically demonstrated the distribution of blood Pb and blood Cd concentrations by year and age groups, and the differences were statistically significant. From 2017 to 2022 roughly, the median blood Pb concentrations showed an increasing trend, with the greatest rising in 2021 and reaching the highest (33.80µg/L) by 2022. And this increase in blood Pb concentrations over the years was present in both the boy and girl groups when stratified by gender (Fig. 1C). The increase in blood Pb concentrations over time was also observed in all age groups when stratified by age group (Fig. 2B). In contrast, median blood Cd concentrations was lowest in 2019 (0.58µg/L) and then increased to reach a maximum in 2022 (0.81µg/L). This was also the case for both the boy and girl groups after stratification by gender (Fig. 1C). This variation was also present in all age groups after stratification by age group (Fig. 2B). The median blood Pb concentrations was highest in the 3-7 years group (24.51µg/L) and the median blood Cd concentrations was highest in the 1-3 years group (0.66µg/L) among all age groups. When stratified by year, the observations differed, with the highest median blood Pb concentrations in the 1 to 3 years group and the highest median blood Cd concentrations in the 13 to 18 years group in both 2021 and 2022 (Fig. 2C).

Next, we calculated the overconcentration rate of the elements Pb and Cd in difffferent gender, age and year groups. Taking Pb > 100µg/L as the standard reference for Pb poisoning, 0.50% of boys and 0.47% of girls had higher concentrations of Pb (Table 3). In addition, blood Pb over 50µg/L could be considered excessive Pb for children due to the critical period of childhood, and 9.73% of boys and 8.85% of girls met these criteria; the difference was significant. When blood Cd concentrations > 2.5µg/L were used as the threshold, 1.9% of boys and 1.75 of girls were above this concentration and the difference was not statistically significant. Between different age groups, the children in Group B (1~3 years group) had a relatively higher rate of Pb > 150µg/L, Pb > 100µg/L and Pb > 50µg/L, and the difference in rates between the age groups was statistically significant. And the children in Group E (13~18 years group) had a relatively higher rate of Cd > 2.5µg/L, but the difference in rates between the age groups was not statistically significant. When 50µg/L was taken as the reference value for BLLs, the lowest rate of exceedance (6.58%) was found in children in 2019 and the highest rate (18.16%) in 2022, the difference in rates between the year groups was statistically significant. When 2.5µg/L was taken as the reference value for BCLs, the lowest rate of exceedance (0.98%) was found in children in 2017 as well as 2020 and the highest rate (3.99%) in 2022, the difference in rates between the year groups was statistically significant.

Finally, we analyzed the correlates that may affect BLLs and BCLs in children employing GLM (Table 4). The results indicated that gender, age, place of residence, heating fuel, frequency of staying in rooms with smokers, and frequency of non-alcoholic beverage intake had an effect on blood Pb concentration in children. Some factors that had influenced blood Cd concentration in children included place of residence, heating fuel, frequency of staying in rooms with smokers, and frequency of non-alcoholic beverage intake. Girls had lower BLLs (OR: 0.52, 95%CI: 0.24-0.89). BLLs were at greatest risk of elevation in the 1~3 years old group (OR: 1.92, 95%CI: 1.23-2.85) , but decreased after 13 years (OR: 0.93, 95%CI: 0.87-0.99) in children. Compared to urban areas, children in rural areas showed lower BLLs (OR: 0.85, 95%CI: 0.68-0.96) but higher BCLs (OR: 1.19, 95%CI: 1.03-1.58). The consumption of oil, coal, pellet or other wood as heating fuel in the home was a risk factor for elevated BLLs (OR: 1.76, 95%CI: 1.14-2.88) and BCLs (OR: 2.05, 95%CI: 1.34-3.71) in children. Children who spent daily in rooms with smokers were more likely to have elevated BLLs (OR: 2.37, 95%CI: 1.41-3.92) and BCLs (OR: 2.59, 95%CI: 1.48-4.06) than children who never spent time in rooms with smokers. Higher BLLs (OR: 2.12, 95%CI: 1.27-3.84) and higher BCLs (OR: 2.18, 95%CI: 1.29-3.87) were also more likely to be observed in those who consumed non-alcoholic beverages on a daily basis. Meanwhile, we also presented the above results more visually with graphs.

There are currently no reference ranges for blood lead and blood cadmium for healthy children in China. Mostly, lead poisoning was empirically determined by blood Pb > 100µg/L and cadmium poisoning by blood Cd > 5µg/L. In addition, differences in biological substrates, age ranges, assays, and geographic regions in published studies made comparisons difficult. In our study, the median BLL of children was 23.48µg/L, ranging from 19.09µg/L to 33.80µg/L between 2017 and 2022. It was lower than the data from researches in Italy (34.00µg/L) [23], São Paulo, Brazil (31.20µg/L) [18], and Iran (24.90µg/L) [24], and lower than the reported data from Nanjing (41.16µg/L) [25], Jinan (49.42µg/L) [26], Beijing (42.8µg/L) [27], Nanning (52.6µg/L) [28], Changchun (60.29µg/L) [29], Wuhan (33.72µg/L) [30] and Hunan (35.00µg/L) [31]. However, it was higher than the data reported for children in the United States (12.00µg/L) [32], children in Spain (11.00µg/L) [22] and adolescents in Sweden (7.10µg/L) [33]. Overall, a total of 0.49% of children suffered from BLL > 100µg/L, which was lower than Nanjing (1.3%) [25], Jinan (1.4%) [26], Changchun (10%) [29] and higher than Hunan (0.33%) [31]. Meanwhile, the median BCL of children was 0.66µg/L, ranging from 0.62µg/L to 0.81µg/L between 2017 and 2022. Our result was lower than the data reported in Jinan (1.47µg/L) [26], Changchun (1.26µg/L) [29] and Hunan (1.00µg/L) [30], China. But it was higher than the results reported by Liu et al. (0.65µg/L or 0.39µg/L) [34], as well as those from Korea (0.30µg/L) [35], Brazil (0.48µg/L) [18] and Germany (0.06µg/L) [36]. The above results indicated that with the introduction of the policy of banning the use of leaded gasoline in 2000, the local government had attached great importance to the publicity and prevention of children's lead exposure, such as the restriction of lead paint and industrial emissions, and also reflected people's attention to healthy living environment and awareness. Nonetheless, our reported data still fell short of the desired level when compared to developed countries such as Europe and the United States. The public health issue of Pb and Cd exposure remains of great concern, given that Pb and Cd exposures originate from a variety of routes, mainly from contaminated air, dust, food, water or jewelry, inhalation of cigarette smoke, or improper handling of the metals themselves [34].

In the present study, both BLLs and prevalence of Pb poisoning (BLL > 50µg/L) were higher in boys compared to girls, similar to other reports [28, 30, 31]. This may be due to higher erythrocyte pressure levels in boys with more sources of Pb exposure [34]. In children, dust is a significant source of Pb exposure, whether it is house dust or ground dust that reach the mouth due to habits such as sucking hands or even licking the surface of an object or placing an object in the mouth [37]. BLLs and BCLs were usually higher in toddlers and school-age children than in infancy and older children due to the natural hand-to-mouth contact activities of toddlers and school-age children and the resulting increased exposure to Pb and Cd through soil and dust [22], which was consistent with the data of our study. The BLLs and BCLs of children in this study varied between years. The year 2020 appeared to be a turning point, after which both BLLs and BCLs in children were more substantially elevated. It was possible that the non-pharmacological interventions measures including restrictions on travel and outdoor activities [38] for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), which was first detected in 2020, kept children indoors with their families most of the time. Children had an increased probability of being exposed to materials used for interior decorating, fuels used for cooking and heating, tobacco smoke from family members' smoking, and ingesting snacks such as beverages. More rigorous conclusions need to be substantiated by more researches.

In this study, we found that rural children had lower BLLs and higher BCLs. It might be due to the higher traffic density, more serious air pollution, easier deposition of outdoor dust, more fancy home decoration materials, and more varied children's toys in urban areas, resulting in the higher probability of children's exposure to lead-contaminated environments. Despite the ban on adding Pb to gasoline, Pb did not break down, so the millions of tons of Pb released into the air from the use of leaded gasoline had contaminated the soil and remained in the air at very low concentrations, especially in urban areas [22]. Besides tobacco, food was the main source of Cd exposure in children [14]. Rural children might pay less attention to food health and hygiene than urban children. And some chemical factories were usually built in suburban areas near rural areas, discharging cadmium-containing effluent, resulting in Cd contamination of soil, which might lead to high Cd content in local crops in the long run. Our study showed that children in households using Oil, coal, pellet or other wood as fuel for heating had higher BLLs and BCLs. This was probably attributed to the fact that the gases and particulate matter emitted from the combustion of these fuels increased the suspension time and concentration of Pb and Cd in the air [39]. Previous studies have reported high levels of arsenic, cadmium, chromium, nickel and lead in Chinese cigarettes [40]. Our results also indicated that children exposed more frequently to tobacco smoke had higher BLLs and BCLs. Many studies have revealed a correlation between BLLs and smoking, with a strong correspondence between Pb levels in air and Pb levels in tobacco, and a decrease with decreasing Pb levels in gasoline [22, 41]. In addition, it has been reported that tobacco plants are readily enriched for Cd and that tobacco smoke exposure affects Cd and Pb much more than other metals [42]. Intestinal absorption of Pb and Cd is susceptible in children than in adults, and Cd is excreted slowly through the kidneys [22]. Our results showed that children who ingested beverages more frequently had higher BLLs and BCLs. Beverage intake might affect micronutrient balance in the body, while deficiencies in calcium, iron, zinc and protein increased intestinal absorption of Pb and Cd [43]. Moreover, beverages contained a large number of food additives, coloring and preservatives, these substances into the human body were easy to aggravate the burden on the kidneys to affect the excretion of Pb and Cd.

There were several limitations to this study. Firstly, this was a cross-sectional design and we were unable to establish a causal relationship between risk factors and BLLs and BCLs. Secondly, the fact that the study sample consisted of the pediatric population of the medical examination center clinic limited its external validity, and it was worth considering whether the data obtained could be extrapolated to the general population. Finally, information on the variables collected was limited and some confounders affecting outcomes might not have been included. The advantages of this study were the high analytical sensitivity of the method for the determination of Pb and Cd in children's blood, with reference to international quality standards, which ensured the accuracy of the results. Data management staff were highly qualified, data collection work was organized and planned, and the data collected were relatively accurate. The study population included children of all ages from 0 to 18 years old. The large sample size of this study reduced selection bias, and the results can provide scientific basis for further intervention by local governments and hospitals.

In this study, we assessed lead and cadmium levels in the blood of 25,920 children aged 0-18 years from 2017 to 2022 in Henan, China. The median of BLLs was 23.48µg/L, around 9.39% of studied children had elevated BLLs. The median of BCLs was 0.66µg/L, around 1.84% of studied children had elevated BCLs. Pb and Cd exposure in this area was relatively low in this study. Boys had higher BLLs and prevalence of Pb poisoning (BLL > 50µg/L) compared to girls. BLLs and BCLs were usually higher in toddlers and school-age children than in infancy and older children. Both BLLs and BCLs were substantially elevated in children in 2020-2022 compared to 2017-2019. Rural children had lower BLLs and higher BCLs. Children in households using Oil, coal, pellet or other wood as a fuel for heating, with higher frequency of exposure to tobacco smoke and beverage intake had significantly increased chances of elevated BLLs and BCLs. These results can provide more attention and corresponding strategies for parents of high-risk children. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first big data analysis of Pb and Cd elements in healthy children in Henan, China. Awareness of children's BLLs and BCLs and their exposure risks provides health policymakers with the information necessary to develop public health measures, community-based preventive interventions, and to promote children's health. It also provides baseline data for future researches.