Background
Methods
Search strategy
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Inclusion Criteria | Exclusion Criteria | |
---|---|---|
Concept | - Explicitly mentions the use of FST to inform the design and development of a pediatric obesity management intervention: - Family theories included in our search strategy were those identified by Skelton et al. [12] in their review of family theories utilized in childhood obesity research, namely FST, Circumplex Model of Family Functioning, Double ABCX Model of Family Stress, Family Stress Model of Economic Strain, Family Development Theory, and Ecologic Systems Theory - Additional family theories included are: General Systems Theory, Calgary Family Assessment / Intervention Model, Systemic Family Therapy | - No explicit mention of FST or related theory in the design and development of the pediatric obesity management intervention - No direct involvement of family members (e.g., school-based intervention with no or minimal family involvement) |
Participants | - Children and adolescents of both sexes, between the ages of 2–18 years - Children and adolescents with overweight or obesity as per the definition in original articles - Targets at least one adult family member with or without the identified child/adolescent with overweight/obesity | - Children less than 2 years of age - Children and adolescents without overweight or obesity (e.g., prevention interventions) - No direct involvement of family members |
Context | - Research conducted in any country or healthcare system, in any setting where healthcare may be delivered (e.g., inpatient and outpatient clinics, the community, home-based settings, etc.) - Publications that dated between January 1980 and October 2023 - All socioeconomic status and sociocultural factors were considered | |
Types of Sources | - Primary research articles published in peer-reviewed journals - Any language - Quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods designs - Published study protocols | - Case studies - Opinion papers - Letters - Gray literature |
Study selection
Data extraction, analysis and synthesis
Results
Intervention / Program Name | Child Age Groupa | Intervention Target | Sample Characteristics | Country | Type of Care Setting | Duration of Intervention | Group vs. Individual Delivery | Delivery Focus | In-person vs. Online | Professionals Involved |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Creating Health Environments for Chicago Kids (CHECK) Trial [28] | SA | Parent/guardian & child | Low-income families | USA | Recruitment in Outpatient Clinic, Home-delivered | 12 months | Individual | Family | In-person & telephone | Dietitians Nurses Exercise physiologist Social worker |
Dyad plus [29] | AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | Recruitment site characteristics: 58% female adolescents; 45% White, 32% African American, 18% Hispanic, 5% other | USA | Weight loss clinic | 24 months | Group & Individual | Family | In-person | Medical providers Dietitians Behavioralists Exercise specialists |
SA | Parent/guardian & child | 42.7% girls; 36% low SES, 32% medium SES, 36% high SES | Spain | Outpatient clinic | 6 months | Group & Individual | Family | In-person | Psychologists Psychiatrist Dietitian- nutritionist Dietary coach Physical activity experts Pediatricians Nurses | |
Exergaming for Health [32] | SA | Parent/guardian & child | Neighborhoods with poverty; 54% girls; 61% White, 25% Black, 8% Hispanic/Asian | USA | Community | 6 months | Group | Family | In-person | Dietician Licensed counselor Medical students |
AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | Hispanic families living in USA; 52.3% females, Income in USD: 62% < 30K, 20% 30K–50K, 9%> 50K | USA | Community | 3 months | Group & Individual | Family, Parent-only & AD-only | In-person | Bilingual park coaches and fitness instructors (trained on problem-posing and participatory learning) | |
AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | African American families 64% female adolescents Parent annual income in USD: 3% unreported, 31% < 24K, 55% 25K–69K, 10% > 70K | USA | Community | 8 weeks [40] | Group & Individual | Family & Parent-only | In-person & online | Trained facilitators (background not specified) | |
Families Improving Together- Telehealth (FIT-T) [42] | AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | Families of diverse backgrounds and identities | USA | Outpatient clinic | 3 days of intensive behavioral intervention + telephonic wellness follow-up (duration not reported) | Individual | Families | In-person & Teleconference | Psychologists Licensed clinicians A postdoctoral fellow with interest in health promotion and program development |
Families on the Move (FOTM) [43] | SA | Mother & child | Latino families. 57.9% girls Maternal education: 71% Less than high school, 14% high school diploma or general education diploma, 14% college graduate or trade school | USA | Community | 2 months | Group | Family & Parent-only & Child-only | In-person | Pediatric nurse practitioner student Primary investigator |
SA | Parent/guardian | Families in a medically underserved region 58% girls 45% black, 48% white, 8% other; 9% Hispanic Parental income in USD: 29% < 20K, 47% 20K–55K, 24% > 55K | USA | Community | 6 months [45]; 12 months [44] | Group & Individual | Parent-only | In-person & online | Dietician Local Parks and Recreation staff | |
Family Weight School Model [47] | AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | 50% female adolescents | Sweden | Obesity center | 12 months | Group & Individual | Family | In-person | Pediatrician Dietician / sports trainer Pediatric nurse Family therapist |
Fit Kids / Fit Families (FKFF) [48] | SA AD | Parent/guardian & child/adolescent | 66% female adolescents | USA | Community | 3 months | Group | Family & Parent-only & Child-only | In-person | Nurse Dietician Behaviourist Exercise specialist |
AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | Latino families, adolescents with prediabetes, 40.1% female adolescents | USA | Community | 9 months 6 months [50] | Group | Family & Child-only | In-person | Trained health educators Trained Physical Activity instructors | |
Lighter Living program (LiLi) [51] | PS | Parent/guardian | 50% girls; 93% native Swedish, 3% European, 3% South American. Parental education level: 10% compulsory school, 60% high school, 40% college/ university | Sweden | Hospital (outpatient) | 12 months | Group | Parent-only | In-person | Therapists Occupational therapists |
Lund Overweight and Obesity Preschool Study (LOOPS) [52] | PS | Parent/guardian | N/A | Sweden | Hospital (outpatient) | 12 months | Group | Parent-only | In-person | Clinical psychologist Occupational therapists |
PS SA | Parent/guardian & child | Hispanic and Black families, 50% girls, 88% Hispanic, [53] | USA [53] | 2 months [55] | Group & Individual [54] | Family | In-person | Healthcare providers MEND leaders and assistants | ||
Motivational plus family weight loss intervention [56] | AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | Low income families, 70% female adolescents, 65% African American, 35% Caucasian | USA | Community | 1.5 months | Group | Family & Parent-only & AD-only | In-person | Not specified |
Multidisciplinary family-based behavioral therapy for obesity (FBBT) [57] | AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | 62% female adolescents | Switzerland | Hospital (outpatient) | 5 months | Group | Family& Parent-only & AD-only | In-person | Licensed counselors |
PS | Parent/guardian & child | 72.15% girls | Netherlands | Hospital (outpatient) | 4 months | Group & Individual | Family & Parent-only | In-person | Dietician Physiotherapist Psychologist | |
Multifamily Therapy plus Psychoeducation [60] | AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | Female adolescents | USA | Hospital (outpatient) | 4 months | Group | Family | In-person | Family therapists (master-level) Trained graduate students |
AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | Low-income, African American adolescents, 77% female adolescents | USA | Community & Home | 6.5 months | Individual | Family | In-person | Therapists | |
Intervention not named [64] | SA | Parent/guardian & child | 62% girls | Sweden | Outpatient clinic | 16 months | Individual | Family | In-person | Nutritionists Dieticians Psychologists Pediatricians |
Parents as Agents of Change (PAC) | SA | Parent/guardian | 52% girls; 73.1% white | Canada | Community [66] | 4 months | Group | Parent-only | In-person | Nutritionists Psychologists Social Workers Physiotherapists Trained on Cognitive Behavioral Therapy [68] |
Positively Fit [69] | SA AD | Parent/guardian & child/adolescent | 59.1% female children and adolescents; 14% African American, 71% European American, 4% Latino, 4% Biracial, 7% Other. Mean monthly income: $4072.54 USD | USA | Hospital (outpatient) | 2.5 months | Group | Family | In-person | Nutritionists Therapists |
AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | African American families, 60% female adolescents. Yearly family income in USD: 33% < 24K, 44% 25K–54 (44%), > 55K | USA | Community | 1.5 months | Group [71] Group & Individual [70] | Family | In-person | Trained graduate students (in Psychology or Public Health) | |
Solution-focused family therapy [72] | SA AD | Parent/guardian & child/adolescent | 40% female children and adolescents | Sweden | Hospital (outpatient) | 15 months | Individual | Family | In-person | Dietician Sports Trainer Pediatric nurse Family Therapist |
AD | Parent/guardian & adolescent | 76% female adolescents, 67.5% non-Hispanic whites. Parental education: 82% college or more | USA | Hospital (outpatient) | 4 months | Group | Parent-only & AD-only & Family | In-person | Psychologists Nutritionists Clinical psychology graduate students Bachelor-level research staffs | |
SA AD | Parent/guardian & child/adolescent | 59% female children and adolescents | Germany | Community | 12 months | Individual | Parent-only & AD-only & Family | Telephone-based | Prevention managers / counsellors |
Who is targeted by existing FST-informed interventions?
In which settings are FST-informed approaches implemented?
How are FST-informed interventions delivered, and which professionals are involved?
Which FST-related concepts are included in interventions and how are these concepts measured?
FST concept and definitiona | Nb of interventions with concept included | Examples | References | Tools used to measure the FST concept (if applicable) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Parenting Skills Skills and strategies that can be useful to parents who are supporting a child in a obesity-management intervention. Effective parenting skills may vary based on existing dynamics within the family but may include limit-setting, active listening and communication, autonomy-support, parental role-modeling, etc. | 16 | Families Improving Together (FIT): Focused on improving parenting skills around communication, autonomy support, and social support [36] Families on the Move (FOTM): Focused on limit setting, re-framing the problem, re-framing parent role and child responsibility, exercising parental leadership, exercising parental general skills, promoting parent–child effective communication, promoting problem-solving skills, increasing self-efficacy in parental role of providing a positive family environment [43] | The Parenting Strategies for Eating and Activity Scale (PEAS) [53] The Parenting Dimensions Inventory (PDI-S) [56] The Authoritative Parent Index [39] Newest Vital Sign [46] Parenting practices scale [33] | |
Family Communication Strengthening both verbal and non-verbal communication among family members to create a supportive environment within the home. Communication strategies (e.g., active listening, openness, respect) can enhance emotional connections, foster productive discussions that can help in problem-solving and decision-making, and allow individuals to feel heard and validated within the family unit | 14 | Families Improving Together (FIT): Targeted family communication strategies, including active listening, using push–pull language, and problem solving [35] | The Dyadic Communication Scale (DOCS) [73] The Family Interactions Topics questionnaire [73] The Family Relations Scale [33] | |
Social / Family Support Encouragement and support from the family and the broader social context to help a child/adolescent succeed in an obesity-management intervention. Support may include emotional, motivational, physical, financial and types of support and resources, as well as fostering a sense of community and solidarity for the individual | 13 | Families Improving Together (FIT): Aimed to foster social support within families through take-home bonding activities, and between families through group activities [35, 37] Multifamily Therapy plus Psychoeducation: Promoted enlisting social support; e.g., determining the type of support needed, who can provide it, and how to ask for it [60] SHINE: Emphasized the importance of peer relationships during adolescence and the role parents play in managing peer relationships and healthy lifestyle behaviours. Adolescents were encourage to bring a friend to [one] session, and friends were integrated into the activities [71] | The Youth Quality of Life (YQOL) Inventory, including a social relationship subscale [49] The Support for Exercise Scale (revised version) [56] The Social Support for Eating Habits and Exercise Scale [61] Parent Relationship with Peer Group Scale [33] | |
Family Functioning Family member roles and interactions that affect day-to-day living within the home environment, including acceptance and understanding of one another, family decision-making and problem-solving processes, and general communication among family members. Simply described as the overall healthiness of a family unit | 10 | Multidisciplinary FBBT: Nutrition-related topics and systemic interventions to facilitate family functioning by reinforcing family resources and improving the emotional climate for adolescents with obesity [57] | The Self-Report Family Inventory (SFI), including the conflict resolution, cohesion, and family nurturance subscales [60] The Family Climate Scale [72] Family Questionnaire (FQ) [31] Family Assessment Device General Functioning [29] | |
Parental Role Modelling The ability of a parent to act as a role model and model healthy lifestyle behaviours through their actions. Recognizing parents as agents of change for their child’s habits and behaviours | 8 | Families on the Move (FOTM): The intervention emphasizes parents as change agents who role model behavioural change by setting goals themselves [43] Family Connections: Parents provide an example of healthy lifestyle behaviours for their child, and model enjoyment of healthy foods and physical activity [44] | The Comprehensive Feeding Practices Questionnaire [53] The Weight Control Strategies Scale (WCSS) [74] Family Experiences Related to Food Questionnaire (FERFQ) [74] Spanish version of the Home Environment Survey-Physical Activity (HES-S) [30] | |
Autonomy Support Creating a family environment that fosters autonomy specific to health behaviours, with the goal of building intrinsic motivation for sustainable lifestyle changes (e.g., encouraging the child/adolescent to provide input, problem-solve, negotiate, participate in shared decision-making, and self-monitor their health behaviours) | 6 | SHINE: Targeted autonomy-supportive communication within the family and parental monitoring specific to activity and dietary behaviours. Intervention curriculum included tools for self-monitoring, and encourages adolescents to monitor their chosen target behaviours with weekly check-ins with their families [71] Families Improving Together (FIT): Intervention facilitators create a climate which fosters autonomy, competence, and belongingness. Adolescents have choices and are provided with opportunities to give input. Parents seek input from adolescents and negotiate rules and behaviour changes together [35] | None mentioned | |
Shared Decision-Making Encouraging collaboration when making decisions, particularly those surrounding health behaviours and activities such as meal planning, physical activity preferences, etc. | 5 | Family Connections: The intervention promoted the involvement of children in decision making for enjoyable physical activity [44] | None mentioned | |
Home Environment Addressing barriers to healthy living that exist within the physical home environment | 6 | Multidisciplinary Treatment Program: Focused on removing unhealthy food triggers from the home environment [58] Family Connections: Provided strategies to restructure the home environment to support healthy food and activity options, while reducing options for unhealthy choices [44] | Home Monitoring Checklist [28] Confusion, Hubbub, and Order Scale [28] | |
Empowerment Providing adequate tools, resources, support, and information to enhance an individual’s confidence surrounding certain tasks or behaviours and helping them achieve a sense of autonomy and self-efficacy to control a given aspect of their life | 3 | LiLi: Empowered parents with the knowledge they need to be able to suggest strategies and set meaningful goals for the family [51] Multisystemic Therapy: Empowered caregivers with the skills and resources to address difficulties inherent in raising adolescents, and empowered adolescents to cope with family, school, and neighborhood problems [61] | None mentioned | |
Family Goal setting Working together to set goals that are important to the family unit as a whole, while taking into consideration things that are important to each individual within the family | 7 | Family Connections: Parents were trained to lead their family through regular goal setting related to physical activity and eating. They learned the process of goal setting using the 5As (assess, advise, ask, assist, arrange), learned how to keep objectives clear, and created a family action plan [44] SHINE: Families worked on target health behaviours in the order of their choice by setting goals, self-monitoring, and receiving weekly feedback [71] | None mentioned | |
Family Problem-Solving Collaboration between a child/adolescent and their parent to identify and resolve a problem | 6 | SHINE: Families learned strategies for effective problem solving (e.g., defining the problem, brainstorming all possible solutions, making a joint decision, and discussing a plan for follow through) [71] | None mentioned |
What are the effects of FST-informed interventions?
FST-informed Interventions | References | Comparison Group(s) | FST Outcomes | Mental Health Outcomes | BMI / zBMI Outcomes | Physical Activity Outcomes | Sedentary Behaviour Outcomes | Diet Outcomes | Other Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ENTREN-F | Rojo, 2022 [31] | - CI (CBT) - CI (Behav. monitoring) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Attendance rate |
Exergaming for Health | Christison, 2016 [32] | - UC (Classroom curriculum) | n/a | Self-esteem = (vs. BL) Self-worth + (vs. BL) | = (vs. UC) | = (vs. UC) | = (vs. UC) | = (vs. BL) | Blood pressure, heart rate, cardio-vascular fitness |
Familias Unidas (United Families for Health and Wellness-FUHW) | Prado, 2020 [33] | - UC (Community practice) | Family communication + (vs. UC) Parent in-volvement + (vs. UC) | n/a | = (vs. UC) | = (vs. UC) | n/a | = (vs. BL) | Parental BMI and parental diet |
Perrino, 2022 [34] | - UC (Community practice) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | + (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | |
Family Connections (FC) | Estabrooks, 2009 [44]a | - CI (Group based) - CI (workbook) - CI (phone based)a | n/a | Eating disorder behavior = (vs. BL) for all 3 intervention groups | + (vs. BL) for all 3 intervention groups | + (vs. BL) only for phone based CI | n/a | = (vs. BL) for all 3 intervention groups | n/a |
Zoellner, 2022 [46] | - CI (Behavioral modification) | n/a | QOL= (vs. BL and CI) | = (vs. BL and CI) | = (vs. BL and CI) | n/a | = (vs. BL and CI) | Engagement in intervention, BP (child and parent), waist circumference (parent) | |
Family Weight School Model | Nowicka, 2008 [47] | - WLC | n/a | n/a | + (vs. WLC) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Fit Kids / Fit Families (FKFF) | Joosse, 2008 [48] | n/a | n/a | Self-esteem + (vs. BL) | + (vs. BL) | + (vs. BL) | + (vs. BL) | n/a | Body circumference |
Lighter Living Program (LiLi) | Orban, 2014 [51] | n/a | n/a | n/a | = (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Mind, Exercise, Nutrition, Do it! (MEND) | Law, 2014 [54] | n/a | n/a | Self-esteem + (vs. BL) | + (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Sacher, 2010 [55] | - WLC | n/a | Self-esteem + (vs. WLC) | + (vs. WLC) | + (vs. WLC) | + (vs. WLC) | n/a | Waist circumference, BP, heart rate | |
Wilson, 2019 [53] | n/a | + (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | + (vs. BL) | n/a | |
Motivational + Family Weight loss Intervention (M+FWL) | Kitzman-Ulrich, 2011 [56] | - UC (Health education) | = (vs. BL) | n/a | + (vs. UC) | + (vs. UC) | n/a | + (vs. UC) | n/a |
Multi-disciplinary Treatment Program | Bocca, 2014 [58] | - UC (Health education and pediatrician follow up) | n/a | Health-related QOL + (vs. UC) Mental health - (vs. UC and BL) | + (vs. UC) | + (vs. UC) | n/a | n/a | Waist circumference, % of body fat |
Bocca, 2018 [59] | - UC (Health education and pediatrician follow up) | n/a | n/a | + (vs. UC) | n/a | n/a | = (vs. UC) | n/a | |
Multifamily Therapy + Psycho-education | Kitzman-Ulrich, 2009 [60] | - CI (Psycho-education) -WLC | Conflict - (vs. CI and WLC) | n/a | = (vs. CI and BL) | n/a | n/a | - (vs. CI and BL) | n/a |
Multi-systemic Therapy | Naar-King, 2009 [62] | - CI (Group weight-loss intervention) | n/a | n/a | + (vs. CI) | n/a | n/a | n/a | % overweight, % body fat |
Ellis, 2010 [61] | - CI (Group weight-loss intervention) | + (vs. CI) | n/a | + (vs. CI) | n/a | n/a | + (vs. CI) | % overweight, % body fat | |
No Name | Flodmark, 1993 [64] | - UC (Dietary counseling) | n/a | n/a | + (vs. UC) | + (vs. UC) | n/a | n/a | Skinfold thickness |
Parents as Agents of Change (PAC) | Spence, 2017 [65] | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Improved retention in program |
Spence, 2023 [68] | - CI (Psycho-education) | Functioning of family system= (vs. CI at 4, 10, and 16 mths) | n/a | = (vs. CI at 4, 10, and 16 months) | = (vs. CI at 4, 10, and 16 mths) | Screen time = (vs. CI at 4, 10, and 16 mths | = (vs. CI at 4, 10, and 16 mths) | Sleep, and parental stress | |
Positively Fit | Steele, 2011 [69] | n/a | n/a | Health- related QOL + (vs. BL) | + (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
SHINE (Supporting Health Interactively through Nutrition and Exercise) | St George, 2013 [71] | - CI (Health education) | + (vs. CI) | n/a | n/a | + (vs. CI and BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a |
St George, 2018 [70] | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Parental PA | |
Solution-focused Family Therapy | Nowicka, 2007 [72] | n/a | + (vs. BL) | Self-esteem + (vs. BL) | + (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Standard Behavioral Treatment + Enhanced Parenting (SBT+EP) | Hadley, 2015 [73] | - CI (Behavioral modification) | = (vs. CI) | n/a | + (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Jelalian, 2015 [74] | - CI (Behavioral modification) | - (vs. CI) | n/a | - (vs. CI) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | |
T.A.F.F. (Telephone-based adiposity prevention for Families) | Herget, 2015 [75] | n/a | n/a | Body dissatisfaction & self-efficacy + (vs. BL) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Markert, 2014 [76] | - No details on control group | n/a | Health-related QOL + (vs. BL) | + (vs. control) | = (vs. BL) | = (vs. BL) | = (vs. BL) | n/a | |
FIT (Families Improving Together) | Wilson, 2022 [38] | - CI (Health education) | n/a | n/a | = (vs. CI and BL) | = (vs. CI) | n/a | = (vs. CI) | Parental light physical activity |
Wilson, 2021 [39] | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Family mealtime | |
Wilson, 2018 [40] | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Retention in program | |
Diabetes Prevention Program among Latino Youths | Peña, 2022 [50] | - UC (Behavioral modification) | n/a | 6-month Weight-related QOL + (vs. BL) and = (vs. UC) 12-month Weight-related QOL + (vs. BL and UC) | = (vs. BL and UC) at 6 months + (vs. BL) and = (vs. UC) at 12 months | n/a | n/a | n/a | Glucose tolerance, insulin sensitivity, insulin secretion, beta-cell function, fat mass, lean mass, HR, SBP, DBP |