Hoarseness as the first symptom in a patient with acute suppurative thyroiditis secondary to a pyriform sinus fistula: a case report

Pyriform sinus fistulas (PSFs) are rare congenital anomalies caused by incomplete obliteration of the third or fourth brachial pouch [1]. PSFs often present with recurrent fever, neck pain, and swelling near the thyroid gland. They more commonly occur in neonates and young children and do not differ by sex [2, 3]. The left side of the neck is the predominantly affected site. Most patients present with a neck abscess and acute suppurative thyroiditis.

Dyspnea may appear secondary to lesion compression due to a neck mass [2, 4]. However, hoarseness has not been reported as the first symptom of a PSF. Herein, we report a case of an 11-year-old girl with a PSF presenting with hoarseness as the first symptom.

An 11-year-old girl was referred to our hospital with the chief complaint of a swollen left-sided neck mass. Two days prior, hoarseness began in the morning, followed by fever and sore throat in the afternoon. On the next day, neck discomfort with tenderness occurred. On admission, she had a fever of 38.2 °C, hoarseness, and an elastic soft mass with mild tenderness on the left anterior neck (Fig. 1). Pharyngeal redness or swollen tonsils were not observed. Laboratory data indicated mild inflammation and thyrotoxicosis; increased white blood cell of 17,500/mm³ (neutrophils, 86.6% and lymphocytes, 8.6%) and C-reactive protein level of 3.4 mg/dL; increased free T4 of 1.98 ng/dL [reference 1.02~1.52 ng/dL], decreased free T3 and thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) level of 2.71 pg/mL [reference 2.78~4.90 pg/mL] and 0.009 μIU/mL [reference 0.62~3.36 μIU/mL] respectively; and an elevated thyroglobulin level of 308 ng/mL [reference 0~33.7 ng/mL]. Contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT) of the cervical region revealed an abscess partially infiltrating the thyroid gland and an air pocket near the piriform sinus (Fig. 2). Pharyngoscopy revealed swelling of the arytenoid region, with purulent retention (Fig. 3). From the purulent discharge, Klebsiella oxytoca was isolated. The left vocal cord was swollen but not paralyzed. No evidence of airway narrowing was identified. Suspecting PSF infection, parenteral treatment with cefotaxime at 100 mg/kg/day and dexamethasone (DEX) at 0.16 mg/kg/day was initiated (Fig. 4). On the day after admission, the hoarseness disappeared, and the fever resolved. On the third day of admission, pharyngoscopy revealed that the swelling had disappeared (Fig. 5). DEX was tapered off within 5 days. On the seventh day of admission, a subsequent contrast-enhanced CT of the cervical region revealed a prominent reduction in the abscess. The patient was discharged on the eighth day of admission, and the antibiotic was switched to oral cefdinir 10 mg/kg/day.

Three weeks after discharge, a barium esophagogram revealed residual contrast in the left pyriform sinus, and PSF was diagnosed (Fig. 6). However, abscess was not detected by ultrasonography. At that time, thyroid function returned to the normal range (FT3, 4.19 pg/ml; FT4, 1.19 ng/dl; TSH level, 2.63 μIU/mL; and thyroglobulin level, 16.4 ng/mL). Chemocauterization was proposed to the patient’s family because this was the first episode of a neck abscess. However, the family did not opt for this method, and the patient is currently under observation without recurrence for a year.

The initial symptoms of PSF include neck mass with or without abscess, acute thyroiditis, and thyroid lesion [1‐3]. In some cases, particularly in neonates, a neck mass compressing the surrounding structure, resulting in dyspnea, has been reported [2, 4]. However, hoarseness, as the first symptom of PSF, has not yet been reported. This study presents a case of PSF with hoarseness as the first symptom preceding fever and neck swelling. Flexible laryngoscopy, performed to evaluate hoarseness, revealed swelling of the arytenoid region with purulent retention. The left vocal cord was swollen but not paralyzed. Hoarseness disappeared with DEX on the day after admission, and swelling disappeared on the third day. Thus, hoarseness may be derived from the swelling of the left vocal cord due to the PSF infection. As vocal cord movement was normal, the hoarseness was not caused by a recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy. Dyspnea has been reported to be secondary to lesion compression in some patients with PSF. However, in our case, no evidence of airway obstruction was identified, although hoarseness, fever, and anterior neck swelling were noted. Hence, the larynx and airways in patients with hoarseness need to be evaluated.

Acute suppurative thyroiditis is a rare clinical condition in childhood because the thyroid gland is remarkably resistant to infections owing to its high iodine content, rich blood and lymphocyte supply, and protective fibrous capsule [5]. Infection with PSF is often reported to cause acute suppurative thyroiditis [1, 6]. In our case, a low TSH level and high FT4 and TG levels suggested that the abscess had partially destroyed the thyroid gland. Considering the suppressed TSH level, high FT3 level may have occurred before admission, although the FT3 level on admission was low. The presence of complicated low T3 syndrome due to infection and decreased intake was indicated. A previous study has reported that low T3 syndrome was associated with acute suppurative thyroiditis because of PSF infection in an adult case [7]. The thyroid hormone levels returned to the normal range within 3 weeks.

Diagnosing PSF can be difficult owing to its rarity, and PSF should be considered when examining neck abscesses or acute suppurative thyroiditis. In the acute phase of infection, identifying the fistula tract is difficult because of swelling of the mucosa and surrounding tissues [6]. In our case, acute-phase contrast-enhanced CT revealed an abscess partially infiltrating the thyroid gland and an air pocket near the pyriform sinus. The air pocket resembled a ductal structure from the pyriform sinus to the thyroid, which was elevated by the abscess, thus suggesting the presence of a PSF. After treatment of the acute inflammation, we confirmed the result with barium esophagogram, confirming the diagnosis of a PSF. As the diagnosis had already been made, we didn’t perform direct laryngoscopy under general anesthesia.

Antibiotics and percutaneous drainage are commonly used to treat PSFs in the acute phase of infection [2]. Surgical intervention for drainage of abscess and closure of branchial arch sinus was proposed to the patient’s family at admission, but the family didn’t choose the methods, and the patient was treated with antibiotics. In addition, corticosteroids were administered to improve the laryngeal swelling. Surgical fistula removal is necessary for treating PSFs [2]. Obliteration of the inner orifice by chemocauterization, laser coagulation, and biocauterization is also effective in the management of PSFs [8]. However, a PSF may not be entirely closed through these methods. Therefore, complete fistula resection is a reasonable treatment method for recurrent cases. In the present case, although we recommended chemocauterization because it was the first episode, the patient’s family did not select this method, and the patient is currently under observation without recurrence for a year.

This study describes a rare case of PSF with acute suppurative thyroiditis with hoarseness arising as the first symptom. Therefore, the possibility of PSF in patients presenting with hoarseness as their first symptom should be considered.